Annotated model answer

Prose essay: an annotated model response

A strong answer with margin notes that show what earns the marks. Every passage and answer here is our own.

Book a Trial ClassOne‑hour paid trial · Same‑day reply · from RM70/hr

The exam-style question

This is a prose essay question, in the style of the Literature in English papers. Read it as you would in the exam, then compare your plan with the model.

Read our original prose extract below. Write an essay on how the writer presents the character of Mr Petherick and our changing attitude towards him.

Use embedded evidence. This is our own teaching passage.

Our original passageapprox. 165 words

Mr Petherick's Ledger

Mr Petherick counted his change twice before he left any shop, and the shopkeepers of Marrow Lane had long since stopped taking offence. He was not, they agreed, an unkind man, merely a careful one, who wore his good coat until it shone at the elbows and heated only the one room. Children thought him a miser and dared each other to knock at his door; he never answered.

What none of them knew was the ledger he kept in the second drawer, its columns headed not with his own expenses but with names: a widow's coal, a boy's school shoes, the doctor's bill for a family three streets away, each sum entered small and paid in secret, each debt he never meant to collect. He counted his change twice, it was true. He had learned that every coin he saved was a coin he could give away without anyone thanking him for it, which was, he had decided long ago, the only sort of giving worth the name.

Our annotated model response

Model response: Prose essay

Writing about character means tracing how the writer shapes our view, often by controlling what we are told and when. You then argue about the effect.

The writer first presents Mr Petherick through the town's eyes as a miser, a man who 'counted his change twice' and wore a coat 'shone at the elbows' to save money.1 This external view is deliberately misleading, and the writer uses it to set a trap for the reader's judgement, just as it traps the children who think him mean.2 The turn comes with the hidden 'ledger', its columns headed 'not with his own expenses but with names', which reveals his thrift as the engine of a secret generosity.3 That each debt is 'paid in secret' and one 'he never meant to collect' redefines every earlier detail: the counted change was saving so that he could give.4 By the closing definition of 'the only sort of giving worth the name', the writer completes our reversal, so we admire the very carefulness we first judged.5

Reading a model answer helps. In a paid one-hour trial, a teacher helps your child write one like it on Prose essay.

Common errors we see

  • Describing the character rather than how the writer presents them
  • Ignoring narrative method (what we are told, and when)
  • Not tracing how our attitude is shaped and changed
  • Evidence summarised rather than embedded and analysed
  • A flat verdict ('he is nice') instead of a developed argument

How this maps to the mark scheme

Examiners mark against assessment objectives. These are the skills the paper rewards.

For prose essay, the objectives in play are listed below. The wording is summarised for Cambridge IGCSE Literature in English (0475) on our qualification page.

  • Show detailed knowledge of the content of literary texts across the three forms (drama, poetry and prose), supporting points with reference to the text.
  • Analyse the ways writers use language, structure and form to shape meaning and create effects.
  • Communicate an informed, sensitive personal response to literary texts.

Marks reward knowledge of the text shown through apt quotation, analysis of the writer's methods and a considered personal response.

Other boards word their objectives differently, but the same skills earn the marks. Your board's official syllabus gives the exact weighting.

Where to go next

Learn the method in our guide to prose essay, then try the prose essay practice tasks. You can browse every annotated model response or see how we teach this in our Literature in English tuition.

When you have written your own answer, take it to a paid one-hour trial lesson and the teacher who would continue will mark it with you.

Next, visit our original practice tasks to try the same method on a fresh task. Our Literature in English tuition page explains how lessons run. When you are ready, the paid one-hour trial is the first step.

Try this question with a teacher

Book a Trial Class

One‑hour paid trial · Same‑day reply · from RM70/hr

Book a Trial ClassOne‑hour paid trial · Same‑day reply
WhatsApp